Tuesday, January 17, 2006

David Thomas Broughton / The Complete Guide To Insufficiency / Rating 8.4

Dripping with inky ambience, his hypnotic sick-souled mantras are simpler than Chasny's and comparable to Youngs' recent outings, but without the playful Arthur Russell flourishes.

I shouldn’t blame the record. I should be cursing the deadly combination of vegan peanut brittle, Irish whiskey, jelly beans, beer, and two menthol cigarettes. The scary part is I don’t even smoke, I mean I NEVER EVER SMOKE but anyhow this particular grouping’s end result was me being sick and then sick some more.

And no this isn’t a regular meal for me, these items happened to be available at a party I was at last night.

The David Thomas Broughton cd is a few months old so with no help from my already muddy brain I couldn’t recall much about the release other than the premise of the recording( church / all in one take) was better than the music itself, and that David’s voice created a chemical reaction in me where I wince like just ate something tart. The same thing happens to me when I listen to Antony and the Johnsons. The mournful shimmer in both of their voices literally doesn’t sit well with my body.

Recalling these two details should have sent a red flag to my brain saying you don’t like this record so don’t play it but I am especially special today, like crash helmet special, so into my cd player it went.

My head is throbbing at a high BPM level. My hands are shaking as type this and I know this record must be calming and beautiful to fans of this genre but Broughton’s voice actually enhances my hangover to the point of unbearable.

The PFM review does this record proper justice and I thank Brandon Stosuy for not mentioning Neutral Milk Hotel in his review. NMH is mentioned on the label one sheet for this record and I have seen the name dropped in many other reviews so it’s nice to see somebody resisted to the temptation.

A double bravo for the Arthur Russell mention as well; it is not only on point but the artist is not well known in even the snobbiest of music circles.

This Broughton cd deserves to be loved but it won't find any in my home. The first person to leave a comment in the comment section of this post saying you would like it can have it. Email us your name and address at tuningforkmedia@hotmail.com and it will be sent tomorrow when my legs aren’t wobbly like a new born giraffe and I can actually make it to the post office without collapsing. WE HAVE A WINNER

Monday, January 16, 2006

"The Smash That Wasn't"

On the right side of PFM's main page you will see and interview with J from Cloud Room and FYI this is not J from Jawbox. Last I heard J(awbox) was in a band with his wife called Channels.

It’s difficult to say what the point of this interview with J actually is. A very public label bashing? A do's and don'ts list for new bands? Outing some of the evils of radio which isn't exactly news? The trials and tribulations of being in an indie band? A piece of irony considering this article / interview talks about the band missing fame when Pitchfork played a roll in melting their hype snowball?

Airing out dirty laundry in the press is dangerous business. It makes for an illuminating read as an outsider but as an artist and an industry person I would say this would make it on my number 1 thing you should NEVER discuss publicly unless your band has cleared all relations and ties with a label. Bands being frustrated with their label is VERY common... like 6 out of every 10 bands but most artists choose to focus on their art with the press not their behind the scenes personal business.

Indie radio promotions could be a full feature story in itself but the side presented in this PFM story is one sided. Many labels can't afford to hire full time employees to work their records to retail, press, and radio so they HAVE to hire an outside company to help them break a record. A good label with a limited staff who believes in a record's hit potential takes these very basic steps to try and actually make it happen. The politics behind these hired indie radio promoters is complex but not all that different from press and retail marketing companies.

Writers and record store employees are also given little perks like guest list action, new releases from a label before others might receive them, free drinks at a show, band swank like shirts, meet and greets with the band; this is all just part of the promotions business.

Part two to this murky subject is the advertisement found on music publications websites and in print. In theory if a record label runs an ad with a publication they stand a better chance to get their records reviewed, their artists interviewed, and have general news posted about their roster by this publication. The more money a label spends with a publication the more they are likely to stand in good favor with them. This isn't always the case, banner ads and full page advertisements don't make a band a hit but this is all part of the game labels have to play.

PFM says " Most of the album's press reflected that strange imbalance. Pitchfork Media's review spent roughly 230 of its 350 words on the single. "

To be more specific Pitchfork gave Cloud Room's S/T release a 6.6 rating and had these final thoughts on the record: "Their naivete is endearing, but it's difficult to shake the feeling that you've not only heard these songs before, they were played more passionately. If only they were just a little more ambitious and written something quite as good as the opening track. "

While this new PFM article offers a glimpse into the lesser known side of the music industry and one bands struggle to swim not sink, I wish there had been a brighter side to the story, a more serious look at the music they make, or even a tie to where the band stands now in present tense.

I don’t believe PFM mentions this but I do know Cloud Room has finished working on recording a new set of demos AKA new material.

The more I think about this interview the more I wonder if this is an infomercial of sorts. Remember that band Cloud Room, the little band that should of? Well they are still chugging along but looking for a new label. Hint hint.

This article is a perfect example of a marketing tool in disguise. It fills a portion of PFM’s main page, offers their readers a look into Cloud Room’s less than perfect path to almost fame but the reader also might check out their cd if they aren’t already familiar with the band or at the very least download their single which won’t die.

Oh…. and if you are of the A & R persuasion have we got a band for you.

UPDATE : Cloud Room has posted a little blurb about this article on their site.

Edith Frost / It's A Game / Rating 5.8

We posted this review back on 11/30/05 and gave the cd away in one of our contests so here at camp TFM this record is old news x 2. Oh yeah, PFM posted their review today hence this deja vu...or deja view I should say.
Here is a the review again in case you missed it the first time. When we review a cd Pitchfork has neglected to cover at the time , we post it in one of three colors to reflect how we liked or didn't like the cd.
Red - hot Mustard = luke warm Blue = leaves me cold
Both folk and country have had quite a comeback over the past few years and what this means for artists falling under either category or under the umbrella of both is the competition is stiff. Edith Frost’s newest release It’s a Game fails to make it into the semi finals no less the final round of best in 2005 show.

Sullen ballads, naked sorrow, moody narratives…there are coffee shops and dorm rooms across America filled with this very same display of sleepy woe, only they probably know how to carry a tune more successfully.

Reaching for the Patsy Cline brass ring is a gutsy recording move but Frost’s carousel of a record goes nowhere traveling at a safe slow pace, never rewarding the listener with a solid compound or prize.

50 minutes of unsatisfying round and round makes the wait for one of the stronger tracks like "Playmate" and “Just a Friend” a test of patience.

Sunday, January 15, 2006

Death Cab For Cutie on Saturday Night Live

Thank you Budweiser for giving us light and refreshing amber entertainment known as Death Cab For Cutie. The SNL standard of two songs were played ("Soul Meets Body" / "Crooked Teeth"). Chris Walla blew the all dark colors motif by sporting a brown and white western shirt. Ben Gibbard was looking more Chia Pet than ever. Somebody needs to tell Nick Harmer his hair is terrifying. Drummer Jason McGerr accented his ripped performance with an Asian inspired headband (?) but with just about every SNL skit featuring the lovely and talented Scarlett Joahansson singing, Death Cab has been overshadowed by Miss Joahanssons umm… ahhhhh…..errrrrr…..ample assets.

The surprise of the night was the use of Smog’s song "Bathysphere" (off of Wild Love) during the deep sea exploration skit. Hate to say it but that 4 second clip outshined Death Cab’s performance too.

(Magic P if for some reason you are reading this, you did one hell of a job making Death Cab sound as good as they get live. High-five!)

Friday, January 13, 2006

Adventures in Indie Rock: Issue 2

The Frenchman and the Beaver: Part 1 of 2

The two men had been walking in the cold for 2 days. Over the floor of the pine forest they trudged, desperate for food, chilled from the snow. In his hunger Tim had attempted to capture a chipmunk with his bare hands, but instead had his pants rip off on a bush. As he attempted to retrieve the pants the Chipmunk had doubled back and pulling the pants off the bush scrambled up a tree. Now pantless and exhausted he continued on. Nearing the end of their strength it was Syd who spotted it first. As they walked at dusk towards the sound of moving water they came across a small encampment next to a rapidly moving stream. A small fire was burning and animal skins had been layed out on the ground. Sitting next to the fire was man warming his hands. He was short, and wearing a large bearskin coat and brown pants over heavy leather boots. He jumped up as he hear them approach and pointed a musket at them.

"Where did jou come from," he asked in a French accent.

"The woods," Syd answered.

The Frenchman stared at the large bearded man who was naked from the waste down, and wore a strange plastic helmet on his head.

"Where are jour pants?" he inquired.

"A chipmunk stole them," Tim said ignoring the firearm and walking to the fire to warm his naked shame.

"Jou are British," the Frenchman said accusingly. "Jou know zat the Algonquin 'ave banned jou from trading with zhem."

"We aren't British," Syd said eyeing the fire that pantless Tim was enjoying.

"Perhaps not," the Frenchman said eyeing Tim. "I do not recognize jour accent. Where are jou from?"

"Brooklyn," Tim said.

"I am not familiar with zis Brooklyn," the Frenchman said, " Jou are not Indian and jou are not French."

"Where are we?" Syd asked trying to change the subject.

"Jou do not know where jou are?" frenchie said narrowing his eyes. "Zhis is Quebec."

"Shit we're in Canada," Tim said.

"What year is it?" Syd continued.

"What year?" this question made the Frenchman stare at syd as if he was insane. "Jou cannot be serious!". Syd said nothing. "Zit is sixteen thirty five of course."

"You son of a bitch Syd," Tim said getting up from the fire, "I told you not to take that pamphlet on quantum mechanics from your dentists office. I told you not to build a time machine. And I forbid you from turning it on!"

"It'll be ok," Syd was trying to be re-assuring.

"Ok?" Tim was furious. "A four hundred year old chipmunk stole my pants! That's about as far from ok as you can get."

The Frenchman looked back and forth at them as if he had encountered a rabid bear. Syd saw his confusion and held out his hand in a friendly gesture. "I am Syd," he said still holding his hand out. "And this is Timothy." The Frenchman took his hand hesitantly and they shook.

"My name, " the Frenchman started, "iz Jean Nicollet. I am a Coureurs de bois."

"Oh," Syd said not knowing what that meant. "Well we are Les Savy Fav."

Jean nodded his head but obviously had no idea what they mean either.

Many hours later the men had settled around the fire and Jean had provided the two with furs to keep warm, and Tim with a tight pair of pants. The Frenchman had insisted on giving tim a backrub, which was much more enjoyable than Tim had thought it would be. After the rub Tim had settled his head onto Jean's lap. Jean had taken his furs and laid them on the ground. Underneath he was wearing what appeared to be an eleborate Chinese robe.

"Whats with the robe," tim asked as he lowered fresh salmon into his mouth.

Jean puffed out his chest proudly. "Zis is a real Chinese robe. I will wear it so zat when i discover the northwest passage to China, i will be properly dressed."

Syd and Tim looked at each other. "Uh," Syd started, "there is no northwest passage to China." Jean looked very dissapointed. "Is that the only reason you are out here?" Syd asked.

"No," Jean said looking at the stream. "I am 'ere in search of a legendary animal. A castor so big, that its fur would be worth a fortune."

"Whats a castor?" Syd asked. Tim looked lovingly up at Jean.

"It is a river dwelling animal. With large teeth. Zey cut down trees with zer teeth and build damns."

"You mean a beaver," tim interjected.

"No. I do not know zhat that iz. I speak of a castor."

"Well how big is this , uh, castor?" Syd asked.

"The indians say it iz zee size of a bear."

Syd and Tim doubted that such a creature excisted. They were silent as they continued to eat their fish. Jean stared down at tim, smiling. He touched the hair on his face.

"Jour beard," Jean said looking intently at it, 'it iz spectacular. I 'ave traveled throughout zee forests of zis continent, but i have yet to see a forest more spectacular zan zee one that grows on jour chin."

Tim felt pride at the recognition of his beard. "I thank you kind sir," he said. "Would you give us the honor of joining you in your hunt for this castor?".

"Yes," jean said proudly," together we shall conquier zee animal. We shall depart at daybreak." Leaning down he kissed Tim on the forehead.

Next week part 2 of 2: The hunt!

Nine Inch Nails / Pretty Hate Machine / Rating 5.6

the new incarnation of Pretty Hate Machine is indistinguishable from the original: no 5.1 surround-sound, no B-side/remix sweetening, no fishnet slipcase/bonus snuff DVD deluxe packaging. And with no garish extras, there's nothing to distract from what turns out to be a horribly dated album, just as awkwardly out of step with the mid-aughts as The Downward Spiral was unexpectedly relevant.

Not to keep beating this street date point into the ground by this release came out back on November 22nd, 2005.

Also check out this link to Ultimate Guitar who ran a small piece in early November about Trent's reaction to this no frills reissue. Needless to say the man isn't happy.

It takes some skill as a journalist to re-review a record that by alternative music standards is considered to be not just one of the key industrial records of all time but THE record that helped bridge industrial music as a genre to the mainstream. I am not surprised to read PFMs thumbs down response to this classic but I am a little disappointed at the attack of its original production value and style which according to PFM is "bumbling" and filled with "too many embarrassingly distinct time-stamps of 1989-ness to ignore".

HELLO this record was made in the late 80's! I don't think that even with the magic of modern day technology should anyone try to make Pretty Hate Machine sound 2000 something.

A path is formed one step at a time and this record is a key and vital brick in this path. Sounding dated needs to be put into perspective and I feel the PFM review failed to position this record accurately in modern music's timeline.

PFM ends their review with : "Unlike The Downward Spiral or Broken, Pretty Hate Machine's re-release reveals the album to be an artifact, perhaps historically valuable, but as anachronistic as Napolean in a water park."

Naturally a re-release which mirrors its original release is disappointing but PFM missing its value otherwise is shameful. You don't have to like the band to see / hear that.

PS: I think Napolean is spelled Napoleon.

What gives?

You know those annoying banner ads on Pitchfork for Neighborhoodies.com? Well for the heck of it I clicked on the site and browsed around. Ignoring the cluttered and creepy MySpace hipster feeling the whole website has, I actually had no idea they carried music and its about now I bet you are wondering why the hell I am telling you this and no this isn't a secret commercial for that company.

The music store features reviews that match Pitchfork's titles du jour ( At least the day I looked. The site has changes since) and you also get to see cute little cartoonish profiles of each writer as well.

I thought Alternative Press was a visual nightmare appealing to teens but this is almost as bad leaning towards Urban Outfitters wanna be DIY cute.

I can't be sure what the deal is but clearly PFM is going steady with somebody new.