Thursday, January 12, 2006
Belle and Sebastian / If You're Feeling Sinister: Live at the Barbican / Rating 9.1
Darn it! I was hoping there would be a Pitchfork review of the original studio version of If You’re Feeling Sinister but there doesn’t appear to be one. It's always fun to look at old ratings especially for a band who has reached the legendary status of "biggest cult bands in indiedom".
I did however find this on PFM:
Belle & Sebastian: The Boy With The Arab Strap[Matador; 1998] Rating: 0.8 - Review by: Jason Josephes
A .8 is a loooong way off from 9.1 and for a live record no less. A friend and I were just talking about how that makes The Boy with the Arab Strap almost three times worse than Morningwood. Yikes!
The ten paragraph B&S live review while a bit lengthy offers an incredible boatload of insight you won’t find very many other places but still one question loomed in the back of my head after I read it.
Didn’t this live record come out in early December?
Yes.
Dec. 6th to be exact.
I can’t decide what sort of mixed message this sends. PFM will jump on reviewing a Boris import because they like the band and want capture the *now* “groundswell of interest but a classic mega indie band like Belle & Sebastian puts out a charity online only release and we finally get the review of it now…mid January*.
What deemed this release lack luster? The online only aspect? PFM and its writers aren’t into live records? B&S have a slipping following? A PFM news story on B&S is posted like once a month so this leads me to believe the latter is not the problem here.
Another point to be made about the PFM review is this: Ignore the buy at Insound or E-Music tagline (which yes I know appears on everything they review.)
This is an iTunes only release.
Back to the record at hand here, I have to be honest with you. I see the word LIVE next to a record title and I cringe. For the most part live records don’t curdle my cream and songs like "If You’re Feeling Sininster" with the sound of grossly out of time crowd claps remind me why.
Yes there is a charm to hearing old familiar songs redone by a favorite band live and in a new light and bands like Yo La Tengo apply this theory to all of their shows perfectly but there still seems to be something ironic about capturing a band live on record. A live show is just that, an action packed once in a lifetime happening. Your surroundings like the audience energy, the venue, the company you brought to the show all add to the experience but on record these nuances vanish and all one is left with is an often questionable production value and the inevitable over the top screamers of the crowd who on record sound a little like nails on a chalk board.
Some people love live records: those who never had the chance to see ______ play live, the crowd noises, the raw recording, and not so perfect performance but I couldn’t feel any the more opposite. Kiss, Frampton, Cheap Trick.....eh. These are some classics but they are still not my thing. To keep things a little more modern I would say the same thing about the recent Bonnie Prince Billy cd but its hard to type and cover my mouth as I yawn.
Anyhow it was a great relief to discover that all in all this live record has been edited down to a more studio like quality. Some folks will be be put off by a live record sounding so squeaky clean and audience energy free but this is Belle and Sebastian we are talking about here. A party vibe record would be wrong all wrong.
I am going to further discredit my review and coolness factor by saying I would take the Wedding Present or Cornershop over this band any day. I am all about the twee to be you and me jangle pop but live, in the studio, and rolled into one but I still can’t call myself a B&S admirer.
Regardless I respect the band for presenting this record to fans for charity sake not to mention how this release will keep their listeners happily distracted until their new record comes out in a month or so. Marketing tool and charity item, everybody wins.
One last point and I swear I will be done. I see that PFM has already reviewed two on line only releases this month (the other being the Pixies). For whatever reason music journalists / most music publications tend to avoid writing reviews of these download only releases so this most recent rash of attention to them either means the times they are a changin’ or that online only labels and releases finally have a decent publicists. It doesn’t take a psychic to predict that we will see an increase of these virtual record releases in months and years to come so maybe this was all just a matter of time.
*In all fairness PFM did run a news story late November telling readers about this charity cd and the release date so I guess you can’t have it all.
Crash Course
Since so many people are new to the site I thought I might give a crash course to the site.
This blog started about a year ago as a joke between a few friends. We never expected the word to spread no less have more than 10 people read our rambles. We are by no means a mega site but the fact that a thousand plus (right now 2000+) people read weekly still blows my mind.
We run this site under secret identities. All of us work in the music industry and have full time jobs in the music world. Our companies don't need to be attached to our thoughts and opinions but on a plus this means we have the inside scoop on a lot of the bands / music Pitchfork writes about. We don't care if you think we are cowards for using codenames, our paychecks come from somwhere else and we have to respect this reality.
I am pitchperfect and I am the main posting fool on this site. If you have unkind words for anything we post just remember that we for the most part keep things above the belt. Ultimately this is about music and not attacking writers as people. If you have something to post, go for it, just try to keep it constructive. We don't know everything. Our opinions are just that, opinions. We sometimes get our facts scrambled and if you know we messed something up or have extra info to ad, please do so. Anyhow if you are going to post stupid shit about me at least get my gender right. Nothing worse than being called dude or a kid when I am neither. As it says in my profile I am a woman in my 30s and the rest of our writers are adults too...tho all the rest are dudes. And not like that should matter anyhow.
If you think you would like to write / help with the site please email us at tuningforkmedia@hotmail.com. I would love to add a few people a little more educated and tuned into electronic music and hip hop. Posting every day no less tracking down at least one record Pitchfork covers a day is an exhausting task. I love it but I will confess, I don't sleep much.
If you run a label or are a publicist please take note. We would love your promos. Not only will we review it but a few of us are also DJs and we try to do a monthly give-a-way on the site where readers can win cds. Our address is listed on the top left side of the front page of this blog.
Also if you know Pitchfork has posted a mistake and you have the correct info please drop us a line.
People always ask why pick on Pitchfork and again because the writers of Tuningfork work in the music industry, we have to look at the site every day. I know it might sound crazy but the news they post, the reviews they run affect all sides of the music world ( indie and major). Radio, other music publications, retail...the list goes on. I think it is important to fact check one of the most powerful music sites in the world and to quote myself, Pitchfork is considered to be a Gods controlling who the next hot band will be and if that is the case than consider me an agnostic. (Black Book Magazine interview)
Lastly and God Bless if you haven't stopped reading by now, we don't always post about Pitchfork. Sometimes we do show reviews, post news, review non pitchfork cds, as of right now I am running (in annoying drips and drabs) the history of UK riot Grrrl and bands you might want to check out if you are into this new wave of girl fronted bands coming out from over seas, we have the greatest occasional short fiction starring members of the indie rock community, there is a running series called confessions of a record addict, and then yes, we have lots of Pitchfork reviews too.
Thanks for dropping by,
Pitchperfect
YOU KNOW YOU WANT IT!!!
Welcome to the first give-a-way of 2006. About once a month we here at Tuningfork try to share the wealth and offer up a few promo cds to our nice readers.
To win all you need to do is:
A) Check the comments section to see if anybody claimed the cd you want to win first.
B) If the cd you want has yet to be requested leave a comment saying your first name and the cd you want. This will let others know the cd has a new home.
C) Email us at tuningforkmedia@hotmail.com your name / address / and cd you want.
You can only win one cd per contest and if you have won a cd from us in the past month or two please give some other readers a chance to win.
It is as easy as that. There is no creepy catch. I don't email spam in the future or mail you adult catalogs three months from now. You get a cd (sometimes more cds if I have some extra stuff sitting around) and a DIY fold / cut / and fill out tuningfork membership card that has zero meaning to about 99.9 % of the world but that .1 % who are record inter-web geeks too will totally be barely impressed. Awesome right?
The goods:
Minus Story - No Rests for Ghosts - Jagjaguwar - promo cd w/ art WE HAVE A WINNER
Japanther - The Living Grace - Menlo Park - sealed brand new!!!! WE HAVE A WINNER
Early Man - Closing In - Matador - no art promo cd WE HAVE A WINNER
Bloc Party - Silent Alarmed Remixed - Vice WE HAVE A WINNER
Solvent - Elevation & Oscillators - Ghostly - no art promo cd WE HAVE A WINNER
Good luck and yes, I will mail cds to people living out of the USA. Non American indie music fans deserve presents too!!!
PS: Selling your prize to a local store makes you a bad bad person. If you don't like the music please pass it onto a friend who will.
Wednesday, January 11, 2006
Later skater
Just a quick note.
Some days I won't be able to post unil real late like. Today is going to be one of those days. What can I say, I have this other full time job that actually pays my bills.
thanks,
pitchperfect
Tuesday, January 10, 2006
Boris / Pink / Rating 8.7
Pitchfork does it again. This is a review of the Boris import cd and don’t let the mention of Southern Lord as the reissue label fool you. Yes this cd is being reissued by SL but I have a reliable source telling me it isn’t slated until at the very earliest APRIL of this year.
When I get a firm street date and an idea of if this cd will have bonus material, new art, and the likes you good people will be the first to know.
PFM says: "But as invigorating as some of their earlier records are, the band didn't begin to gain a substantial following outside the metal world until 2003's outstanding Akuma No Uta-- parodying the artwork of Nick Drake's Bryter Layter-- struck a chord with independent music fans seeking an antidote to the more polite pop sounds of the Shins, Sufjan, and Death Cab for Cutie."
The PFM Boris review on the whole is fine and I expect the 8.7 to be on target but for many people who follow metal and experimental music a fondness for Boris started when the Keiji Haino split cd Black: Implication Flooding was released on Inoxia back in 1998.
Boris then gained further exposure in 2001 as described by the Southern site:
" "Absolutego", their full-length debut, came out in 1996 on the band's own Fangs Anal Satan imprint but was unavailable in the rest of the world. for years, a situation that was remedied by the Los Angeles-based Southern Lord label reissued the album in early 2001 along with a bonus track and new packaging."
Thanks to Southern Lord, Hydra Head, and a growing acceptance of all that is heavy/experimental/ and noise a whole new group of people have been exposed to Boris and in turn become fans.
I reported this news back about 3 months ago but here it is again: Boris and Sunno))) recorded together in Seattle during their last tour so we can all look forward to this collaberative project being released on Southern Lord later this year.
Lastly here are a few bits taken from an interview with Boris. The band talks about their ever morphing sound which PFM made a remarked upon in their Pink review.
There are two sides to what you do. When you release something like "Dronevil," do you worry about confusing some of your audience, who might not understand the more experimental work?
We're not afraid to try anything, because we have some fans who like the experimental side, and some who like the heavy rock, and some who like both. When we use the name boris, we're experimental, but when we use BORIS, we're heavy. This is how we let people know what we're doing. If someone likes the experimental stuff, maybe they'll listen to the heavier stuff with a more open mind, and vice versa. It's all rock. Some people get confused by the different styles, but we're OK with that. We want to challenge people. If we challenge them, we're having an impact.
Do you see Boris as having anything in common with musical trends like progressive or German "Krautrock," in addition to the stoner/sludge movement?
We love prog and Krautrock! We love psychedelic music, the kind that enters your mind, and takes you on a trip to anywhere. Its influence naturally finds its way into our music, but we're trying to do something different, something beyond. We don't want to be a throwback. There's nothing to be gained from playing it safe, you have to grow. We don't think too much about originality, or our image, but we want something to connect us to now.
Monday, January 09, 2006
UK Riot Grrrl and their Friends: Lung Leg
Band:Lung LegWhere: Scotland
When: – Mid to late 90’s
Members:
Amanda / Jade Green (Tadpole)
Annie Spandex
Jane Egypt (Dick Johnson)
Morine Quim
Why I picked this band for my list: See the Wikipedia history below.
History: "Lung Leg were an indie band from Glasgow, formed in 1994, and disbanded 1999. They were known for a sparsely recorded stop-start kind of music influenced by C86 and riot grrrl as much as by post-punk bands such as The Fall and The Fire Engines. Singer Jane McKeown is the sister of John McKeown from The Yummy Fur and the two bands often toured together and even sometimes sounded similar.
The original line-up, Jane McKeown ("Jane Egypt"), "Annie Spandex", "Jade Green" and Maureen Quin ("Mo Mo Quim") released two EPs in 1994 and 1995, both of which were "single of the week" in the NME. Jade left in 1996 to be replaced by Todd. This second line-up recorded their debut album, Maid To Minx.
Jane was also the drummer in label-mates Dick Johnson, and when Maureen quit Lung Leg in 1997 it was from this band that they recruited her replacement, Phillipa, who featured on their last single in 1999. "
Bonus: Lung Leg toured w/ Yummy Fur and The Make Up ( in support of the split 7” which helped to expose Lung Leg to American kids...me being one of them.
Style: Bis and Lung Leg were both from Glasgow, Scotland and released similar sounding early singles, danceable pop presented with a feminine sting. In the end I favor Bis but the Lung Leg track “Krayola” is so incredibly infectious that it would turn anyone into a fan.
Discography: KRS = Kill Rock Stars
KRS259 Hello Sir 10"/CDEPOther Discography
POMP 001 In Spelunca 10" Compilation (Vesuvius)
POMP 007 Maid to Minx LP/CD (Vesuvius)
POMP 010 Right Now Baby 7" (Vesuvius)
Made to Minx/Juanita 7" (Southern)
split 7" w/ The Makeup (Southern/Vesuvius) * Favorite Lung Leg song
Slampt 28 Elastic Jet Mission Compilation LP (Slampt)
GUIDE 17 Theme Park 7" (Guided Missile)
PIAO! 2 The Negative Delinquent Autopsy 7"
PIAO! 5 Shagg the Tiger 7" EP
FLOP 02 Easter Egg-splosion 7" Compilation (Basketcase)
SHag 13.06 Club Beatroot Pt. 6 7" Comp. (Flotsam & Jetsam)
NANA 1 Astral Angora 7" Compilation (Nana)
Pitchfork gave their Maid to Minx record a 1.7 rating.
This is a brutal politically incorrect review from PFM. I think Howard Stern could have written a more thoughtful review. This whole piece is so wrong, so fucking shitty that it’s hardly worth dragging out but here are a few samples of the piece.
PFM says: “Lung Leg's another technically- crippled, fashion- conscious band out to prove that, yes, anyone can play this three- chord crap called punk," and look cute doing it, too. Hell, after listening to Maid to Minx, the Muffs' Blonder and Blonder suddenly sounds like the Stooges' Funhouse. But as much as I love to exaggerate, I'm almost, like, totally serious here. And now, because I'm such a big lover of rock n' roll mascara, let's just examine the thick layers of this band's overall make-up.”
“In a nutshell, these songs are only slight variations on the same awful song. Consider the B-52's if fronted by Yoko Ono and with Jad Fair on guitar, and you may get some idea of how inhumanly obnoxious this band is. And how these Scots can manage to sound so damn Japanese, I'll never know.”
“Lung Leg is not a gaggle of hairy- legged, muscle- bound lesbians screaming songs about cutting up males. Just look at the back cover-- there you'll find the band in all their photogenic Seventeen magazine glory. Personally, I'll take belligerent gorilla lesbians over these precious kewpie dolls any day. I can only recommend that you run far, far away from Maid to Minx.”
I would really like to believe PFM wouldn’t dare post something this offensive today but this is a great reminder of just how flawed Pitchfork can be.
UK RIOT GRRRL and their Friends : Mambo Taxi

Band: Mambo Taxi
From : UK
When : Early 90's
Members:
Ella – Guitar / Vocals
Andrea – Organ
Lenie – Bass / vocals
Anjali – drums / vocals ( Also was in Voodoo Queens and most recently is a solo artist. See my Voodoo Queens post for more info on her)
Karin - drum (replaced Anjali)
Delia - played guitar in Mambo Taxi, The Phantom Pregnancies and Baby Birkins. She drummed in The Action Time and sang in The Family Way. She's also in The Sinisters playing guitar and dances in the The Actionettes. Bass in the A-Lines.
Why did I pick this band for my list: The UK / USA press was all about this band during the Riot Grrrl explosion and they played on Riot Grrrl associated bills. When I bought these records over a decade a go I didn't know anything about them but the clerk at the local record store insisted they were a UK Riot Grrrl band I shouldn't miss out on.
Band History: I got nothin'. There are brief mentions of the band on line but I couldn't find anything truly informative about the band at all. If you know something please post it in the comments section!
Sounds like: "Mambo Taxi for example, were inspired by sixties garage rock, by retro bands such as Thee Headcoats/Headcoatees, and soundtracks to films like American Graffiti and Hairspray as well as by punk."
My two cents: I agree with the above description though the singles I have suggest a more basic 1-2-F-U punk element; garagey yes but with more feedback and sneer then your basic girl garage group. I must confess this is one of my least favorite bands of this time period.
Discography: I can't find a complete listing ANYWHERE so here is what I have in my collection / know about.
"Prom Queen" 7" / B-side -"Insecure" / Clawfist records
"Do you always dress like that in fornt of other peoples boyfriends?" / B-side - " I Want to Marry a Serial Killer" / Calwfist Records
"Poems on the Underground / B-side - A & E / Clawfist Records
In Love With - 12" ( lp????) / Clawfist Records
Wat Tyler / Mambo Taxi split 7" / limited to 500 / Honey Bear Records
I know there must be a few comp tracks out there so if you know any please post a comment.